Home
Q&A
Not sure if I'm hearing it right

Not sure if I'm hearing it right

1
vote

I'm trying to translate some Spanish audio, but I'm not sure of the wording.

What I think is being said is,"Does she like popular music?".

What I'm hearing is, "¿Hay ya le gusta música popular?"

Is the "hay ya" correct? If it is, what would be the translation for it?

1192 views
updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by wgschultz
See if haya works. Conjugation of the verb haber. - h1deaway, Mar 11, 2010

7 Answers

2
votes

Actually, listening to it again, I think they're saying:

"¿A ella le gusta música popular?"

Makes more sense, but would the leading "a" be correct?

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by wgschultz
0
votes
  1. Person or Persons

The personal “a” is used where the direct object of a sentence is a person.

"Ella" not the direct object here, is it?

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by wgschultz
"le" is the direct object and "a ell" disambiguates the 3rd person reference. - samdie, Mar 11, 2010
More accurately, there is no direct object. "le" is the "dative of interest" which resembles (in form) an indirect object pronoun. - samdie, Mar 11, 2010
0
votes

Haya is the present subjunctive of haber to have

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by nizhoni1
True but irrelevant. See the follow-up message. - samdie, Mar 11, 2010
0
votes

"¿A ella le gusta música popular?" is correct.

In this case, the a ella is used for clarification.

To whom is popular music pleasing? Popular music is pleasing to her.

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by mar959
0
votes

"¿A ella le gusta música popular?" is correct.

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by Gekkosan
0
votes

Well I think the a is wrong with out it, it would say "She likes popular music."

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by Pandagamesorg
0
votes

So, would it make sense in that context?

updated Mar 11, 2010
posted by wgschultz