Home
Q&A
"He de saber"

"He de saber"

1
vote

I'm reading a comic and one character says this:

Miss Rudolph no está y yo he de saber cómo vais en su asignatura.

I looked up the phrase on Google and it seems like it means "I am to know..."

Is this correct?

Would that be translated as:

Miss Rudploh isn't here and I'm to know [or "I'm to find out"] how you're doing in her subject [or "class"].

In other words, "I'm expected to know" or "I'm supposed to know" or even "I'm expected to / supposed to find out"?

1839 views
updated Mar 7, 2010
edited by Luciente
posted by Luciente

3 Answers

3
votes

Cuando el verbo "haber" está seguido de la preposición "de + infinitivo" tiene significado obligativo, es decir una acción que debe ser hecha.

When the verb "haber" is followed by the preposition "de + infinitive" it has a must meaning, this means an action that must be done.

En inglés esto se muestra con "have to" asi que puedes, perfectamente, traducirlo por "I have to know" y es exacto.

In English this is showed as "have to" so you can, perfectly, translate it for "I have to know" and it is accurate

updated Mar 7, 2010
posted by Zizoun
Muchas gracias! - Luciente, Mar 7, 2010
1
vote

Miss Rudolph no está y yo he de saber cómo vais en su asignatura.

Why is "aquí" not present in that sentence?

updated Mar 7, 2010
edited by Gustav-R
posted by Gustav-R
With "estar" you can leave off "here/there" and it's understood. Like on the phone -¿Está Julio? (Is Julio there?) -No, no está. (No, he's not here.) - Luciente, Mar 7, 2010
In that case means that Miss Rudolph is just absent. - Zizoun, Mar 7, 2010
1
vote

This can't be directly translated with accuracy. He de saber means I should know.

updated Mar 7, 2010
posted by 005faa61
Muchas gracais! - Luciente, Mar 7, 2010
Ojalá pueda aceptar las dos respuestas...! - Luciente, Mar 7, 2010