Home
Q&A
Weird sounding "nos los" is it OK?

Weird sounding "nos los" is it OK?

2
votes

I'm a beginner so bear with me. The translation engines are so inconsistent that I can't "check my work" against them. Real simple example: He buys the balloons for us. -> Él nos compra los globos para nosotros. (long form) -> Nos los compra. (shortest form) Is this really correct? "Nos los" sounds funny so does it get changed to something else or is it that simple? And if it's a rule that you have to have the indirect object pronoun then why do the translation engines seem to get so confused by it? Thanks.

8913 views
updated Mar 18, 2010
posted by chull

3 Answers

5
votes

It appears correct to me.

In Spanish, whenever there are two objects to a single verb, you must place the indirect object pronoun before the verb.

In this instance, the pronoun "nos" is an indirect object pronoun, while "los" is a direct object pronoun. When the sentence, "Él nos compra los globos para nosotros," is shortened to, "Nos los compra," it translates to, "He bought them for us."

As always, I suggest waiting for confirmation of my answer as I have a penchant for dolling out incorrect information. smile

updated Mar 18, 2010
posted by hithere3387
2
votes

Completely right "nos los" however people commonly say "no los" which is wrong, so when you talk right you sound "weird"!

updated Mar 18, 2010
posted by AntMexico
1
vote

This seems correct.

updated Mar 18, 2010
posted by baileywonders