Home
Q&A
Would you pursue fighting for an A?

Would you pursue fighting for an A?

0
votes

Most of us know that last semester that I was accused of cheating by one profesor. This same profesor gave me an A- cuando I made an A. At my school an A- is not a 4.0, it is a 3.7 I believe and I really needed that A to pull up that B-.

My question is, what would you do?

Tengo el mismo profesor this semestre and I don't want him to hold anything against me.

1478 views
updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by sunshinzmommie

6 Answers

2
votes

For all practical purposes, it makes little sense to "fight" for this A. The distinction between a 3.8 and a 4.0 is unlikely to make much difference in the mind of a prospective employer (who usually only cares that you actually hold a degree and who will, generally, be more interested in your actual work experience and personality than with your GPA).

Don't lose site of why you are in school in the first place -- to learn. The fact that a professor has given you an evaluation that you believe does not reflect your actual effort or understanding can not diminish the fact that you know in your heart that you put what you needed to into that paper and that because of it you experienced growth in both skill and ability. This is what you were after. This is what you received.

In the end, the difference between an A and an A- is trivial at best. You have to question whether you really need this professors validation to be happy or whether you can be satisfied in how much you have grown in your own abilities. After all, when you finally graduate, this professor will barely be an afterthought in the remainder of your life; whereas, what you have learned will last you a lifetime.

Good luck with whatever decision you decide to make grin

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by Izanoni1
good points.well said - nizhoni1, Jan 22, 2010
very well said :) - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
1
vote

Keep up the good work!

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by nizhoni1
Thank you :) - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
1
vote

I truly appreciate the advice you all have given me. I have decided against it, also following my husbands advice. Much love to you all smile

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by sunshinzmommie
1
vote

If you're going to fight this, you need to have a strong case to show that you did not cheat (I know, guilty until proven innocent) as well as strong evidence that the assumption that you did cheat negatively affected your grade.

I find it hard to believe that it negatively affected your grade if you got an A- instead of an A. When I was in college, I had several professors give me an A- when I thought I deserved an A because of a general personal preference in the way that I performed in some subjective area of the course. Occasionally, the same professor awarded me with a higher grade than I thought I deserved for much the same reason.

My point is, it's nearly impossible to prove either, and you necessarily need to be able to prove both. I'd let it go as to avoid negatively having your grade affected by this professor setting higher to impossible standards for you for the remainder of your career.

However, I don't think it would be a bad idea to talk with the professor about your grade, as long as your able to do it in a polite and even keeled manner. Perhaps, try to find out why the professor thought you cheated, and do what you can to alleviate their fear that you are an individual who would cheat and might continue to cheat.

Advice complete.

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by hithere3387
I appreciate your words. - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
I can prove that I had an A but I could never prove that i did not cheat. - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
Yeah, it's stupid, but it's unlikely that you'd be able to convience someone without upsetting them. - hithere3387, Jan 22, 2010
1
vote

Do you have to have a certain GPA for reason beyond personal pride?My thoughts would be to work hard and make A+ on your current courses to pull up any old grades. Maybe if that professor sees the consistency of your work he would consider changing it after that point in time.Fighting for anything in the past takes away from the present, so chose your battles carefully.

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by nizhoni1
I do have to keep a 3.0 for my full ride :) but I still have a 3.8 with the A-. - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
I appreciate your last sentence sweetie, really put things into perspective. - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010
Trying to think practically - nizhoni1, Jan 22, 2010
1
vote

In which subject were you accused of cheating?

updated Jan 22, 2010
posted by webdunce
Advanced composicion - sunshinzmommie, Jan 22, 2010