Home
Q&A
Does anyone have tips for rolling r's?

Does anyone have tips for rolling r's?

3
votes

I was wondering if there are any tricks taught to young children in Spanish speaking countries to provide help for ease with rolling r's. Also, if you can't roll r's is it seen as a speech impediment to native Spanish speakers?

7187 views
updated Feb 24, 2012
posted by alfritz07

9 Answers

3
votes

I still can't trill r's without conscious effort, but I do have one exercise that is helping me. Start with a motor, or purring sound. This will be at the back of your tongue, almost in your throat, like a guttural trill. Then maintain that vibration but move it forward along your tongue until the tip of your tongue is vibrating at the back of your teeth. It may seem odd, but if you practice you can eventually learn to move the trill back and forth along your tongue. The point of this exercise is to get the tip of your tongue used to vibrating like that.

updated Jan 21, 2010
posted by 008f2974
2
votes

Best thing a friend mentioned, and seems to work best for me, is that in english our tongue is always near the front teeth/lips when we talk. Gotta pull that sucker back a bit for the rrs to come out right, I find it hard doing them when they follow a vowel in the word, but if I deliberately get my tongue back a bit from the teeth and just below the roof of my mouth, it does help. Then repeatedly practice once you get the feel for it.

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by lmaika
1
vote

Studies in linguistics show that human beings are capable of producing every kind of sound. Because certain languages do not use certain phonemes (distinctive sounds), people grow up never using them and lose the ability to produce them. Also, there is no physiological basis for speech impediments like stuttering. It's actually psychological and it in turn affects the physical.

In other words, if you want to roll r's you need to keep practicing it. It's the only way you can bring it back. The older you are, the harder it is. Which is why older Americans learning Spanish sound ridiculous compared to high school students learning Spanish.

updated Feb 24, 2012
posted by royaljlee
Whoa! I'm an older person, and my gracious, can I ever rrroll my rrrrr's! (No offense taken, though.) - 0057ed01, Jan 19, 2010
I am not sure that the latest research has shown that there is no physiological basis for speech impediments such as stuttering. There may even be a gene involved that we share with a kind of canary...One which has the occasional member which "stutters". - Janice, Jan 19, 2010
Just curious. Would you please reference your source for: "Physiological basis...", and also for "The older you are..". Thank you. - Rolest, Jan 19, 2010
I know that this is old, but still. Look up the work of Allen R. Braun, specifically the paper "Altered patterns of cerebral activity during speech and language production in developmental stuttering. An H2(15)O positron emission tomography study." - January_molasses, Feb 24, 2012
1
vote

Just do a search under the "Answers" tab and you should find plenty of threads.

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by Eddy
1
vote

Piece of cake! Just pretend like you are saying 'd's' with the "r".

Try carro: "Carddo"

Once you can feel your tongue kind of "bouncing" off your soft pallete, you have it.

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by Rolest
0
votes

I always thought all Spanish children could roll their r's, because they grew up hearing it so they could just do it. Well, you learn something new every day. . .Pero, es muy dificil para mí porque mi lengua materna no es el español.

Mi profesora de Español 1 (la clase introductoria de la lengua de español, hace muchos años en el pasado) enseñóme para repetir la palabra:

Batera

Es muy útil, y me ayudó mucha. ¡Debes intentarlo! grin

updated Feb 1, 2010
edited by june10
posted by june10
0
votes

Sometimes you can use the American "D" sound. For example: To pronounce the name Míriam the Spanish way, try saying "medium" the American way

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by jaimetayag
Indeed, when I copy down what I am listening to, I often have written a "d" (sometimes even an "l" where an "r" was spoken by the native Spanish speaker.....:-( - Janice, Jan 19, 2010
0
votes

I over roll my r's and actually need to get down when you are supposed to roll them and when you aren't!

Also, I have met maybe 3 men ever who didn't like the soft purring sound right up next to their ear. wink

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by Lasairfiona
0
votes

¡Práctica! ¡Práctica! ¡Práctica! Es muy dificil en primero apreniendo pero es facil con práctica. Practice, Practice, Practice! It is difficult (to roll R's) when first learning but easy with practice.

updated Jan 19, 2010
posted by Juan20112