Home
Q&A
Usted ha / vosotros habeis. arent they the same thing?

Usted ha / vosotros habeis. arent they the same thing?

1
vote

I'm confused.

Vosotros habeis cantado muy bien- you have sung very well

Usted ha escrito un poema bonito- you have written a pretty poem

if they are both indicative present perfect sentences, why do they use different words for " you have"? or can you use both of them?

3387 views
updated Dec 12, 2009
posted by pepsiwriter37

4 Answers

4
votes

Vosotros is plural "you" used in Spain when speaking to a group of people with whom you are familiar. You'd say to your amigos, "Vosotros habéis cantado bien."

Usted is a singular "you" used all over the Spanish-speaking world to a single person in a formal or unfamiliar situation. You'd say to your teacher, "Usted ha cantado bien."

updated Dec 11, 2009
posted by 003487d6
Oh and don't forget Ustedes, a plural, formal "You." in Spain and the only plural "You" in the rest of the Spanish-speaking world. Ustedes han cantando bien. - 003487d6, Dec 11, 2009
2
votes

Better yet, there are four kinds of "you". Singular (tú/usted, both singular) and vosotros/ustedes (bothe plural).

updated Dec 12, 2009
posted by samdie
jejej oh si claro.. oops. - 003487d6, Dec 11, 2009
0
votes

Better yet, there are four kinds of "you". Singular (tú/usted, both singular) and vosotros/ustedes (bothe plural).

Maybe 5 if you wish to consider vos (voseo)..

updated Dec 12, 2009
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
0
votes

First of all you have to understand that there are two types of 'you' in Spanish. In this case, 'vosotros'= you all (plural), 'usted'=you(singular)

updated Dec 11, 2009
posted by Seb79