Home
Q&A
how do you do? (what do you answer?)

how do you do? (what do you answer?)

3
votes

¿Qué contestas cuando alguien te saluda diciendo "how do you do"?

9005 views
updated Nov 28, 2009
posted by AntMexico
Gracias por todas las respuestas, no imaginaba que encontrarĂ­a un gran tesoro de conocimientos. - AntMexico, Nov 26, 2009

17 Answers

5
votes

It's still used quite frequently in my little corner of England - mostly in more formal situations.

For example, my bank manager or solicitor (Lawyer in USA speak) would greet me with "How do you do?". It's always accompanied by a handshake, and the correct response is, indeed, "How do you do?"

In practice, any attempt to use this greeting as an opening to actually discuss your health would be frowned upon - it doesn't really imply any interest on the part of the person asking!

updated Nov 28, 2009
posted by sheila-foster
I agree Sheila - but our language has been modified in many parts of the world. - ian-hill, Nov 28, 2009
Yes, and that is a good thing too. A language should change to accomodate the different people using it. The big trick is to know what to use where, isn't it? - sheila-foster, Nov 28, 2009
4
votes

Believe it or not, proper answer is:

How do you do?

It is more a phrase than an actual question. If you are really interested in the origin of the phrase, check out this link

I think it's more common in Britain than in North America. Personally, I've never heard it spoken.

EDIT: I just realized that robertico had already posted this link. red face

updated Nov 28, 2009
edited by sofiasonja
posted by sofiasonja
I used to hear this years ago when people were introduced... kind like "mucho gusto".. an automatic response. - Valerie, Nov 26, 2009
4
votes

Normalmente se dice esta frase cuando darse a conocer a alguien. Es como "¿Cómo está?" y es un poco formal. Puede contestar así.

Good/fine/well thank you, it's nice to meet you

A veces, esta frase se usa en lugar de "How are you?" o "How have you been?" o "How are you doing?" pero es un poco más formal. Puede responder

Good, thank you. How are you?

I'm fine, thanks. How about yourself?

OK I guess, how have thing been going for you?

I'm doing good. And how are you doing?

Hay otros modos tambien que puede responder y depende de ti y tu estilo personal.

updated Nov 26, 2009
edited by Izanoni1
posted by Izanoni1
2
votes

I think it's more common in Britain than in North America.

It's not the most common greeting, but I definitely use it, and it does get used with some frequency in southeastern USA (Florida, Alabama, Georgia, etc.)

We say it fast, though. It's more like "Hadayadoo?"

It is used in exactly the same way as "How's it goin'?" and "How are you?" and can take all the same responses.


Interestingly, and tangentially, when we say "How about yourself?" we usually say it in one of two ways (here in the southeastern USA):

  1. How 'bout yourself?
  2. Hows about yourself? ("Hows about" is pronounced /how'-zuh-bout/)

The "s" on hows above is totally for word flow, and it makes an English z sound.

By the way, it is incorrect to write "how 'bout" or "hows about" unless you are quoting someone and wish to convey the actual sounds they made as opposed to the words they thought they said.

updated Nov 26, 2009
edited by webdunce
posted by webdunce
1
vote

"How do you do?" Is a phrase that is quite formal but also quite normal in England. The correct answer would be "How do you do?"

You do not say something like "Fine thanks!"

The Spanish would be "Mucho gusto"

In other words it is only used the first time you meet someone (unless you have forgotten that you have already met them - embarrassing)

updated Nov 28, 2009
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
1
vote

Im doing okay.

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by ronljr1985
1
vote

Ian said:

You do not say something like "Fine thanks!"

"How do you do," in the U.S. anyway (and in areas where the language has a strong U.S. influence), is a conventional expression that can be used as both a greeting and upon being introduced to someone. As such it would be perfectly to respond with a "Fine thanks!"

It literally means "how's your health," but has lost much of this original meaning and has simply become a wrote expression used for the two situations mentioned above.

In the U.S. corruptions of this phrase exist and include:

How-do

Howdy [probably more of a cross between "hello" and "how do you do" in meaning]

"Howdy" is somewhat common in southern portions of the United States but not nearly as common as the stereotyped image of the common southerner might lead some to believe.

As Heidita and Ian have alluded to, I don't think that it is used exactly the same way in the UK or in areas of the world where the dialect has more of a British influence. In these areas it apparently does not function as a catch all greeting and is used solely as a response to an introduction.

updated Nov 26, 2009
edited by Izanoni1
posted by Izanoni1
I agree...here in the U.S. it's a greeting, and "I'm doing well. How are you" is a perfectly fine response. - --Mariana--, Nov 26, 2009
Well... I live in the US and I think its a slightly old-fashioned way to acknowledge an introduction. :) - Valerie, Nov 26, 2009
1
vote

I'm doing fine?????link text

updated Nov 26, 2009
edited by 0068e2f4
posted by 0068e2f4
I am evolved away from it orginal unless you talk about your health in detail, a simple I'm fine is enough - BellaMargarita, Nov 26, 2009
1
vote

Many Americans seem to answer:

I'm good.

Seems to be very fashionable, mind you, a student says this and he will be marked wrong.wink

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by 00494d19
This is indeed very common and colloquial. However, as has been pointed out above, it's a response to "how are you" rather than "how do you do?" - Valerie, Nov 26, 2009
1
vote

Im doing fine. how about yourself?

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by ronljr1985
0
votes

I read somewhere that the Canadians sometimes say "I am tickety-boo"........

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by 00f2b5a1
And, thus, we have placed a border between ourselves and them. :) - webdunce, Nov 26, 2009
That sounds cute, - BellaMargarita, Nov 26, 2009
i am Ca nadian and that makes little sense but i guess it could be used. it is more about the state of something not a person - jamesgv0r, Nov 26, 2009
Like an engine in a car. It was running ticketee boo. meaning it was running well - jamesgv0r, Nov 26, 2009
0
votes

In my part of western Canada, "How do you do?" is a more formal phrase. Usually when being introduced to someone for the first time. More familiar would be "How are you" How's it going" How ya doing". I think I would compare it to "Como este usted" as a formal greeting.

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by jamesgv0r
0
votes

I have really only experienced this greeting in a playful manner. When someone wants to be more light-hearted. Almost mocking the formality of the phrase. And the response is usually an equally light-hearted, "Charmed, I'm sure!"

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by aloshek
0
votes

"How do you do" es un saludo como "How are you?" por lo menos en Los Estados Unidos. "I am fine or I am well" son respuestas apriopadas en mi opinion. Como puedes ver, el uso de esta expersion y la respuesta apropriada pueden variar dependiendo del region.

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by BellaMargarita
0
votes

Here, in New England, simply "Good. And you?"

updated Nov 26, 2009
posted by Yeser007
I agree! - --Mariana--, Nov 26, 2009