Home
Q&A
Winning stars/video game or earning a reputation/learning site

Winning stars/video game or earning a reputation/learning site

4
votes

We have lots of amazing people on this site. I haven't been here long, but I am starting to see the difference in the winning and the earning of the stars. Any comments?

2049 views
updated Nov 9, 2009
edited by gloriadean
posted by gloriadean

4 Answers

7
votes

I think the admin have put in place a system that works for a lot of people (sort of an incentive base system). People want to see progression in their learning and want to know when something is correct or not so much. smile I've seen reputable people "move" up the reputable board and deserved the move up. I think there is always some flaws with systems where you are voted upon (look at our government?!) because you "team" up with others and say the "I'll vote for you if you vote for me" kind of thing. I would say to this, if you are doing that, it is not productive and you probably really don't want to learn spanish, you are probably just looking for some kind of validation to skills you really don't have. This is my humble opinion and I hope it didn't come out poorly. If it did, sorry. I think this site is an unbelievable learning tool to learn spanish and I am proud to be a part of it!!! smile

updated Nov 9, 2009
posted by Jason7R
Now this is a comment worth an honest vote. Well put! :-) - chaparrito, Nov 9, 2009
3
votes

...we feared it would be abused, however, we were wrong.

I think the point-limits put in place help prevent abuse (i.e. 10/day for voting; 200/day for getting voted up; 200/day max.) Chris obviously had the right idea and I think he has done a good job implementing it.

.

I am, however, having trouble finding official information on the site (FAQs, Reference) about why we would vote, or what is 'vote-worthy'. The FAQ topic simply explains the mechanics but not the 'why's and wherefores'. Common sense (is it really?) would rule out the 'vote-for-me-I-vote-for-you' attitude; and there have been other threads on the subject, but...

Any chance that additional information on this topic could be posted in an easily accessible spot? smile

updated Nov 9, 2009
edited by chaparrito
posted by chaparrito
Kudos to Chris!!! I love the restrictions because of this fact. :) - Jason7R, Nov 9, 2009
1
vote

you "team" up with others and say the "I'll vote for you if you vote for me" kind of thing.

Hi Jason, excellent point.

I remember Eddy and me vividly, pointing this out to Chris when he implemented the new system, we feared it would be abused. however, we were wrong wink , we are glad to see, it has not been abused and people have found it to be a challenge.

updated Nov 9, 2009
posted by 00494d19
I totally agree and that's why I brought up the point that if people actually did this that they were not here to learn spanish. :) - Jason7R, Nov 9, 2009
0
votes

I don't see what the problem is. You vote for the best answer. It's that easy smile Depending on the situation/question, the best answer may be the most helpful and technically correct grammar answer for example, or just plain an answer that you find funny on a general discussion thread. Whatever suites the situation. smile Granted, what you and someone else thinks the 'best answer' is might vary.

updated Nov 9, 2009
posted by cheeseisyummy
I actually don't see a problem either. I'm thinking of new people wanting to better understand the forum. :-) - chaparrito, Nov 9, 2009
I think having the differences of what is the best makes the forum great! I agree with the fact that it must agree with whatever suites the situation. :) - Jason7R, Nov 9, 2009