Home
Q&A
Why "de" and not "sobre"?

Why "de" and not "sobre"?

2
votes

In the sentence "...Y cayó de cabeza" someone fell on his head. But 'de' means "of". So he fell 'of' his head? Is there any logic here or is this an irregularity?

1614 views
updated Oct 15, 2009
posted by gedim

4 Answers

3
votes

Nikki did a good job of giving examples of this usage. The particular reason is that in this case the preposition "de" is used to express the manner in which something occurred. It answers the question in what manner/how did he fall?

He fell (in this manner) on his head - de cabeza

He fell (in this manner) on his knees - de rodillas

Cayó de pie, como los gatos - He landed on his feet

updated Oct 15, 2009
edited by Izanoni1
posted by Izanoni1
1
vote

I guess it´s just one of those things that is what it is....

cayó de rodillas... He fell on his knees.

cayó de cabeza... He fell on his head.

Just like the phrase... DE rodillas te pido... on knees I´m asking, like you are on your knees pleading to someone for something..

You can also say...

cayó de su bicicleta... He fell from his bicycle.

updated Oct 13, 2009
edited by NikkiLR
posted by NikkiLR
0
votes

de would be of, and sobre would mean about. so in this case, de would be closest. smile

updated Oct 15, 2009
posted by xoxsarasxox
Yes, but my reasoning came from a Hebrew-Spanish dictionary... - gedim, Oct 15, 2009
0
votes

Estar de pie - To be on your feet (standing)

and as nikkis said,

Estar de rodillas - To be on your knees (kneeling)

updated Oct 13, 2009
posted by Eddy