Home
Q&A
"Come una naranja." Why no "ella"?

"Come una naranja." Why no "ella"?

1
vote

In the video in 1.4 - Food and Regular -er Conjugations, the first word is sometimes in parenthesis, but she says it. Like "(Usted) come una fresa." Would you really say the word usted, or is it just telling you what type of speech it is?

Also later in the video, there is a girl eating an orange and it says the correct Spanish is "Come una naranja." Why no "ella" or anything before come? I don't understand why sometimes there is, and sometimes there isn't a pronoun. They are used early in the video, but not later.

2273 views
updated Oct 20, 2009
edited by 00494d19
posted by Jeffaz1622

5 Answers

0
votes

ella would not be correct. well maybe but if u want to be formal than use come. I know that means he/she eats a orange. Come goes along with the ser congugation.

updated Oct 20, 2009
posted by 5109
0
votes

Solace and Jeff, welcome to the forum smile

updated Oct 6, 2009
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

Sunshine, that is a good answergrin

Jeff, I changed your title, as "stupid questions" do not exist on this forum, all questions are welcome.

In spanish the general idea is: do NOT use subject pronouns. But the teacher includes some(in brackets) to distinguish. In Spanish you do this by context, we do NOT use subject pronouns.

Have a look at this thread:

subject pronouns

updated Oct 6, 2009
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

Ditto what the other guy said and also adding that in spanish, you don't normally need a pronoun because the verbs are conjugated and that explains who is doing what.

At first, I didn't get it either or I didn't like it, one of the two but now I understand. It makes things easier kind of because there are already so many things to say/type that omitting even one word like a pronoun really helps! It gets the brain working more. Good Stuff!!!!!! grin

updated Oct 5, 2009
posted by Solace99
hey, i am a dudette!!!!! hehe - sunshinzmommie, Oct 5, 2009
0
votes

It is not necessary to say the usted, they are putting it in () to make it known to a Spanish learner that they are talking to you in usted form, as opposed to the tú form which would be conjugated differently. If there is no no (Usted), you can usually assume it is he or she, whoever was previously being talked about.

I hope i have said this correctly. And I hope that it helps smile

updated Oct 5, 2009
posted by sunshinzmommie