Home
Q&A
when a group of people have both female and male...

when a group of people have both female and male...

0
votes

when a group of people got female and male, ist we should use ellos? or we must use ellas? or both also can?

2807 views
updated Sep 1, 2009
edited by 0074b507
posted by danielyap102343
Correct spelling, punctuation etc. is mandatory on this forum, thanks. - 00494d19, Sep 1, 2009

7 Answers

3
votes

If a group is only female, use the feminine plural. If the group contains even one male, be it 400 females and one male, use the male plural, ellos.

updated Sep 1, 2009
posted by idahorsegirl
1
vote

Here in the southern US, if we are referring to a single person and the gender is not obvious, we naturally use "they" or "them." Technically, we are supposed to use "he" or "him."

Trust me, this is not an attempt to stomp out sexism. Whether you are sexist or not, if you are in the southern US, you probably use "they" frequently as a 3rd person singular pronoun. I certainly do.

  • An example:
  • "Hey, John, someone´s gonna drop some supplies today. Will you give them this paper?"
  • "Sure, Boss, when´ll they get here?"

We might even know the gender of the person we´re referring to, but if we use a generic pronoun like "someone," we´ll probably use "they" or "them" later in reference to the same someone.

It irritates grammar teachers everywhere, but I think it´s kind of neat.

updated Sep 1, 2009
edited by webdunce
posted by webdunce
Foreigners do not need to imitate this behavior. - webdunce, Sep 1, 2009
0
votes

En realidad esta regla debe molestar a las mujeres

Pues ahí es donde te confundes, lo que a las mujeres nos molesta es esta idiotez de miembros y miembras . ¡Esto sí nos molesta! mad

updated Sep 1, 2009
posted by 00494d19
jejeje - --Mariana--, Sep 1, 2009
0
votes

Sounds sexist to me

Funny coming from an American, you do this all the timewink :

Hey you guys, why don't we.... (to a group of young people , both female and male) wink

updated Sep 1, 2009
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

En realidad esta regla debe molestar a las mujeres.

updated Sep 1, 2009
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
0
votes

Sounds sexist to me. wink

updated Sep 1, 2009
edited by CalvoViejo
posted by CalvoViejo
0
votes

According to our Spanish natives here, don't be shocked if you see ellos y ellas where people are trying to be politically correct, but gramatically it's ellos for a mixed group.

updated Sep 1, 2009
posted by 0074b507