Home
Q&A
Is it correct to use a serial comma in Spanish writing?

Is it correct to use a serial comma in Spanish writing?

0
votes

For example, in English, either sentence is correct:

"The flag is red, white, and blue." OR "The flag is red, white and blue."

Some style guides recommend it, while others suggest it's only personal preference.

Which is correct in Spanish?

"La bandera es roja, blanca, y azul" OR "La bandera es roja, blanca y azul"

Thanks!

5912 views
updated Aug 27, 2009
posted by emilyeck

3 Answers

0
votes

For me the first sentence is not correct. "The flag is red, white, and blue." does not need the comma before the and; but I think it is used more like that in American English. As for Spanish I am not sure.

updated Aug 27, 2009
posted by ian-hill
I'm an editor (English), and I always use a comma before the last item in a series. - --Mariana--, Aug 27, 2009
Really? I am surprised at that, I thought it was a mistake. - 00494d19, Aug 27, 2009
it is a newer grammar. i went to college in the early 90s and was taught to put the comma before and as well. but we were also informed that maybe a decade or two prior omitting it was correct. - webdunce, Aug 27, 2009
It is correct to use the comma or not use the comma. The reason that it has become more popular not to use the comma before the and is newspapers. They need all the room they can get for the articles, so they remove the third comma in a series. :) - Debiera, Aug 27, 2009
0
votes

If all the elements are connected, the last comma is omitted.

If you use "y", but you are going to say something that is not part of the previous sequence, but in these cases, there is a pause when you speak anyway.

updated Aug 27, 2009
posted by lazarus1907
0
votes

In Spanish the last comma should be omitted.

"La bandera es roja, blanca y azul" is correct.

updated Aug 27, 2009
posted by --Mariana--