HomeQ&ACan you use "para" to clarify sentences with indirect object pronouns?

Can you use "para" to clarify sentences with indirect object pronouns?

0
votes

Ex:

Yo le compro las flores para Jane.

(I bought flowers for Jane.) Can you also write it this way too?

Yo compro las flores a Jane.

Thanks!

6448 views
updated MAR 18, 2010
posted by kmckenna

1 Answer

3
votes

We've had some interesting discussions on this previously if you care to research old threads.

Of course, you can use "para" in your example.

The question that was previously discussed is whether the prepositional phrase beginning with para still obligates the use of the i.o.p. "le".

Your 2nd example sentence is incorrect. With "a Juanita" you definitely must include the i.o.p. "le".

According to (I believe it was Heidita) the use of "para" and whether an i.o.p. is also required is still being debated by the powers that be.

I've read a few articles that gave examples and you will see para... used in this context both with and without the i.o.p., so it is controversial.

For an example, look at our Reference article on i.o.p.'s/

indirect object pronouns

Overall, the article seems to advocate using the i.o.p. when the prepositional phrase beginning with para is used.

Mi madre te compró un libro para ti. (My mother bought a book for you.)

But it also contains sentences where it is not used with the para prepositional phrase.

Él compró unos regalos para nosotros. (He bought some gifts for us.) - For whom? For us. Us = nos

Él nos compró unos regalos. (He bought us some gifts.)

I'm not sure whether this is simply an error on not.

updated MAR 18, 2010
edited by 0074b507
posted by 0074b507
The fist prase is not right. It can be either "Mi madre te compró un libro" or "Mi madre compró un libro para tí". Using both the "te" and the "tí" in that phrase is wrong. - 00e657d4, FEB 3, 2010
SpanishDict is the world's most popular Spanish-English dictionary, translation, and learning website.
© Curiosity Media Inc.
SOCIAL NETWORKS
APPS