-ía endings in dictonary listed as conditional tense and imperfect?

Bookmark and Share
1

I'm a bit confused. When I looked up the words recogía and solía in the dictionary on this site, it is written that these are first person conditional tense forms of these words. I wonder if this is an error. In the context of what I am translating, the imperfect past tense is appropriate not the conditional which I believe should have endings of -ría not just -ía. Could someone check this for me?

Preguntó 31 de Ago
  • 235
  • 15
  • 23k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 68k
  • 268
  • 17k
Heiditaadmin

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Very good post, victoria, thanks. - Heidita 31 de Ago

12 Respuestas

1

What exactly did you see the error in the dictionary as you cannot look up solía or recogía

Actually, when you type in recogía it brings you to this page:

recogía

Near the top of the page it reads:

"recogía" is the first person singular conditional of the verb recoger. View conjugation.

I think that this is what she was referring to. If, however, you look up the full conjugation of the verb then you will find the verb form conjugated correctly (i.e. recogería-Conditional, 1st person, singular

When you look up **recogería** it also brings up this line

"recogería" is the first person singular preterit imperfect of the verb recoger. View conjugation.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 9.6k
  • 103
  • 69k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 9.6k
  • 103
  • 69k

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Thank you. Does Heidita realize that there is an error that needs corrected? - qfreed 31 de Ago
I don't know...I was just trying to clarify what Victoria-pet was writing about - Izanoni1 31 de Ago
NO, I did not realize. I did not even SEE this line, only the conjugation. - Heidita 31 de Ago
It is showing the same mistake for "solía". I have reported both to Paralee. - Eddy 31 de Ago
0

HI victoria, while you are right with your suggestion, the conjugation given on this site states this:

Condicional recogería recogerías recogería recogeríamos recogeríais recogerían

Condicional solería solerías solería soleríamos soleríais solerían

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 68k
  • 268
  • 17k
Heiditaadmin

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

]Wher exactly did you see the error in the dictionary as you cannot look up soliá or recogía, but must look up soler and recoger? When you follow the link to full conjugation of the verbs both are conjugated correctly in the conditional and imperfect.

[soler][1

[1]: soler

[recoger][1]

[1]: ecoger

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 31k
  • 56
  • 262k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 31k
  • 56
  • 262k

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Not true. You can type in a conjugation of the verb and it gives you the infinitive. - Eddy 31 de Ago
0

Solería?? What on Earth is that?

This verb is defective, and it is not conjugated on perfective or future tenses (that include the conditional). It doesn't make sense, as it an imperfective verb means "used to...". How often do you say "I would use to go shopping"?

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

Solería?? What on Earth is that? This verb is defective, and it is not conjugated on perfective or future tenses (that include the conditional). It doesn't make sense, as it an imperfective verb means "used to...". How often do you say "I would use to go shopping"?

I was wondering why when I checked the conjugation of soler in the RAE dictionary it didn't show many tenses. So I checked one of the little pocket verb books and it shows 8 tenses of soler that are not used.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 31k
  • 56
  • 262k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 31k
  • 56
  • 262k

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Soler is a defective verb, however, the form itself is in theory correct. So would be solerá...which is not used either of course. - Heidita 31 de Ago
0

It doesn't make sense, as it an imperfective verb means "used to...". How often do you say "I would use to go shopping"?

Oh, I don't know. How about...

I would use to go shopping when I would use to buy groceries when I would used to have a refrigerator to put them in Or would that be incorrect ? tongue laugh

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 9.6k
  • 103
  • 69k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 9.6k
  • 103
  • 69k

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Sure would (be incorrect). - samdie 31 de Ago
I thought that the little face next to the (obviously incorrect) sentence that I was trying to be humorous, but now that I look at this, I can see how you would think that I was asking a serious question. - Izanoni1 31 de Ago
Sorry, I will try to refrain from any more attempts at humor as they don't seem to translate. ;-) - Izanoni1 31 de Ago
0

I would use to go shopping when I would use to buy groceries when I would used to have a refrigerator to put them in Or would that be incorrect ? tongue laugh

You tell me: English is not my first language. What about "I will be use to speak Japanese?". Does this one sound any worse? Anyway, even if any of them are correct in English, they makes no sense in Spanish whatsoever.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

As to which is worse, it's a toss-up. They're both broken English. - samdie 31 de Ago
No Lazarus, I am quite sure that your English is impecable, it was my attempt at humor that fell flat - Izanoni1 31 de Ago
0

"I will be use to speak Japanese?"

Not like this, however the sentence :

I will be used to speaking Japanese when I have lived in Japan for 3 years.

I find nothing wrong with that.

This would be the equivalent of:

soleré hablar japonés si.....

AS this verb is defective we have to use: Estaré acostumbrada a hablar en ......

However, the English version sounds fine to me.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 68k
  • 268
  • 17k
Heiditaadmin

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

Anyway, I did not even know that our dictionary made a search and indicated the infinitive of the verb if you typed in a conjugated verb! big surprise

I thought only WR did that! That is a major improvement. Great!

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 68k
  • 268
  • 17k
Heiditaadmin

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

I will be used to speaking Japanese when I have lived in Japan for 3 years.

I find nothing wrong with that.

Yes, but then we're cheating here, because the tense of "to be" is future (I will be...), but the "used to" remains as "used", like a past participle or an adjective. In Spanish, however, "soleré" is only future, so they are not the same thing.

Anyway, they are different, and "soleré" is unacceptable (and ridiculous) in Spanish.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

Thanks for all of the input and confirming what I suspected about the dictionary on the site. Anyway, I am not concerned about the usage of soler (being "incorrect") as it is part of a dialogue in the book Cajas De Carton by Francisco Jimenez. This is a book of stories about very poor migrant farm workers from Mexico who came to work in the fields of California in the 1940s. The language is not formal or "correct." It is the language as it was spoken in Jimenez's family and time.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 235
  • 15
  • 23k
Editó 31 de Ago
  • 235
  • 15
  • 23k

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

0

Anyway, I am not concerned about the usage of soler (being "incorrect") as it is part of a dialogue in the book Cajas De Carton by Francisco Jimenez.

The book is used imperfect, which is correct. It is the dictionary that it is listing wrong tenses.

Contestada 31 de Ago
  • 52k
  • 34
  • 468

comentarios - Los comentarios son para añadir observaciónes cortos a una consulta.

Contestar esta pregunta


¿Cómo formateo mi consulta?

¿Ya eres miembro?

¿Has olvidado tu contraseña?
Recuérdame

¿Todavía no eres miembro?

Nombre de usuario
Contraseña
Email
Sexo
Cumpleaños   
Mándame la palabra del día gratis
Cuando te registras, estás de acuerdo con los Términos de Servicio y la Política de Privacidad.